So, five months after my initial review, I find myself revisiting the Coen Brothers’ “A Serious Man.” The first viewing left me in a state of befuddlement and I spent nearly a month formulating an opinion on the film. Now, after a third viewing of the film, I can say it ranks very high in the quirky brothers’ distinguished filmography. Ultimately, in my opinion, the key to understanding the film comes from the Jewish adage which opens the film:
“Receive with simplicity everything that happens to you.” – Rashi
This wise adage can be applied to the unfortunate incidents within the life of Larry Gopnik, the film’s main character. Larry, a physics professor and devout Jew, finds his life spinning out of control as his wife divorces him, a disgruntled student bribes him for a better grade, and his eccentric brother Arthur moves in with the family. As the film progresses, Larry’s problems only worsen. His redneck neighbor disregards Larry’s property line. Larry’s son, Danny, complains about the fuzzy television, while his daughter, Sarah, is secretly planning to get a nose job.
Dumb-founded by his recent string of bad luck, Larry seeks help from his religion, his lawyers, and colleagues. Each gives him advice, most of it helpful, but Larry still cannot find any answer to his sufferings. The Junior Rabbi tells him to simply enjoy life and appreciate all that God has given us. For example, “just look at the parking lot.” Another Rabbi tells him just to wait it out. All of your problems will soon disappear, “kind of like a bad toothache.” The final, and most well regarded of the rabbis, gives the simplest response: “be a good boy.” Larry heeds their advice, but fails miserably in trying to apply them to his unfortunate circumstances.
While the Coens seem to recognize the wisdom in the rabbis’ advice, they also realize that life is unpredictable and that, while this advice can certainly help one’s life, it ultimately has no bearing on one’s fate. In other words, good works, although admirable and even integral to flourishing of the human person, do little to prevent bad things from happening to you. This theme pops up several times in the Coens’ filmography. In 1996’s “Fargo,” the good will of a chirpy police officer fails to prevent crime from pervading a good-natured Midwestern town. In 2007’s “No Country for Old Men,” the violence of the new world outmatches the skill of an old, moralistic deputy.
As the amoral Anton Chigurh, the crazed serial killer in “No Country,” exclaims with dry certainty, “You can’t stop what’s coming.”
Dumb-founded by his recent string of bad luck, Larry seeks help from his religion, his lawyers, and colleagues. Each gives him advice, most of it helpful, but Larry still cannot find any answer to his sufferings. The Junior Rabbi tells him to simply enjoy life and appreciate all that God has given us. For example, “just look at the parking lot.” Another Rabbi tells him just to wait it out. All of your problems will soon disappear, “kind of like a bad toothache.” The final, and most well regarded of the rabbis, gives the simplest response: “be a good boy.” Larry heeds their advice, but fails miserably in trying to apply them to his unfortunate circumstances.
While the Coens seem to recognize the wisdom in the rabbis’ advice, they also realize that life is unpredictable and that, while this advice can certainly help one’s life, it ultimately has no bearing on one’s fate. In other words, good works, although admirable and even integral to flourishing of the human person, do little to prevent bad things from happening to you. This theme pops up several times in the Coens’ filmography. In 1996’s “Fargo,” the good will of a chirpy police officer fails to prevent crime from pervading a good-natured Midwestern town. In 2007’s “No Country for Old Men,” the violence of the new world outmatches the skill of an old, moralistic deputy.
As the amoral Anton Chigurh, the crazed serial killer in “No Country,” exclaims with dry certainty, “You can’t stop what’s coming.”
This sentiment is played with throughout “A Serious Man.” As Larry melts down, he searches for answers in religion, tradition, and even physics. But, ultimately, he lives in a world of unpredictability. While he can try to ascribe meaning to all the unpleasant parts of his life, while he can think that he is being punished for some moral wrongs, while he can valiantly try to incorporate a set of principles into his everyday, these actions have absolutely no meaning when confronted with the unpredictability of fate.
Thus, if there is a God, we do not know the method to his madness. Therefore, we must live our lives to the fullest. We must make the most of our circumstances and work to improve the lives of those around us. We must not overcomplicate the nature of our existence. And, perhaps most importantly, we must appreciate what we have been given.
But, at the end of the day, we have no idea if our actions take on any greater meaning. So, ultimately, it doesn’t matter if Larry accepts or denies the bribe from the disgruntled student. While this action is – and should be – important to Larry’s individual moral character, his life does not depend on it.
The tornado of fate can intervene at any moment. It can ruin your life with one swift blow. It shows little concern for you well being. You can’t make a deal with it to ensure your safety. You can't lessen the effect of its deadly blows.
You can’t ignore it. You can’t fight it. You can’t stop what’s coming.
Thus, if there is a God, we do not know the method to his madness. Therefore, we must live our lives to the fullest. We must make the most of our circumstances and work to improve the lives of those around us. We must not overcomplicate the nature of our existence. And, perhaps most importantly, we must appreciate what we have been given.
But, at the end of the day, we have no idea if our actions take on any greater meaning. So, ultimately, it doesn’t matter if Larry accepts or denies the bribe from the disgruntled student. While this action is – and should be – important to Larry’s individual moral character, his life does not depend on it.
The tornado of fate can intervene at any moment. It can ruin your life with one swift blow. It shows little concern for you well being. You can’t make a deal with it to ensure your safety. You can't lessen the effect of its deadly blows.
You can’t ignore it. You can’t fight it. You can’t stop what’s coming.
Do you have any thoughts on "A Serious Man?" Race to the comments to leave your interpretation of the film's meaning.
No comments:
Post a Comment