In “Harry Potter and Half-Blood Prince,” the sixth installment of the “Harry Potter” series, the characters in J.K. Rowling’s massive epic are finally given some room to breathe. Instead of trying to cram several elements into one film, director David Yates and screenwriter Steve Kloves are able to pare things down to the absolute essential. Thus, instead of feeling bloated like Yates’s previous Potter venture, “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix,” this film feels more developed.
The film – obviously a continuation of the previous five – sees Harry Potter (Daniel Radcliffe) continue his relationship with Professor Albus Dumbledore (Michael Gambon), develop feelings for his best friend’s sister, and learn more about the Dark Lord Voldemort’s past. That plot synopsis will either make sense to you, or it will not. If it does not, I suggest going to the beginning of the series and start your “Harry Potter” adventures there. It is important to note that this film does not stand on its own. If a newbie were to walk into this film, they would be terribly confused. This is a continuation of the previous five (as I mentioned above) and one really needs to see the previous installments before diving into this one. In fact, one of the best things about this film is how continuous it is with the rest of the “Potter” films. While the rest of the films feel like separate entities, “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince” feels much more connected to the other films in the series. Several elements from the previous film, such as the Marauder’s Map, the Room of Requirement, and the Invisibility Cloak, all return and create a wonderful continuity between this film and the ones that precede it.
The acting – as almost always in the “Potter” films – is top-notch. It seems as if the producers have managed to cast nearly every famous British thespian by now. It is a joy to watch such greats as Alan Rickman, Helena Bonham Carter, Maggie Smith, and Julie Walters create such vivid characters in each film. While much of the adult cast is not given a whole lot to do, they still put in solid performances and never act like they are “above” the material. The newest addition to the all-star cast is Jim Broadbent, who plays Harry’s new potions teacher – Professor Horace Slughorn. Broadbent adds a level of nuance to the performance by expertly mixing the character’s broad comedy and tragic regret. And it’s all in his face. Broadbent is such an expressive actor that one can clearly see all the emotions that are running through his characters.
While the adult actors have always been great, the teenage actors have certainly evolved from there rather flat performances in earlier films. Although Dan Radcliffe – who really improved in film number five – is not given much to do in terms of emotion, he manages to give Harry a more proactive feel. But this film really belongs to Rupert Grint and Emma Watson, the two young actors who play Harry’s best friends Ron and Hermione. Grint, in particular, is able to really flex his comedic muscle in scenes involving his annoyingly clingy girlfriend Lavender Brown (Jessie Cave). Meanwhile, Emma Watson really gains more control over her characterization of Hermione. While Watson has been known to overact in past films, she strikes a much better balance in this film and is able to convey teenage heartbreak without it seeming childish or melodramatic. And that is a really hard task to accomplish. Also, Tom Felton adds some much need complexity and conflict to the character of Draco Malfoy. And Evanna Lynch still feels perfectly cast as the wonderfully eccentric Luna Lovegood.
As one can tell from reading my descriptions of the performances, this film involves a good amount of teenage romance. This element both adds and subtracts from the quality of the film. While the humor and angst conveyed through the romance sub plots are a nice relief from much of the darkness of the film, they sometimes feel a bit too fluffy – particularly in the film’s middle section. Being a Harry Potter devotee, I do not mind it because I think it deepens the characters, but I can definitely see how it could annoy some non-fans and it does cause the pace to lag in a few scenes. Also, the relationship between Harry Potter and Ron’s sister Ginny Weasley (played by Bonnie Wright) does not work at all. It feels forced, awkward and sometimes even creepy. Radcliffe has absolutely no chemistry with Wright, and Wright feels miscast. She does not really embody the spunkiness of the Ginny we see in the books.
Even though the pace is still a bit uneven, David Yates has definitely improved as a director. His scenes have more rhythm and pack more of a punch. Although he still ends some scenes rather abruptly, the scenes feel more complete and less rushed than his previous work in “Order of the Phoenix.” And the film looks beautiful. Director of Photography Bruno Delbonnel and Yates give the film an interesting visual look that makes it stand out from most recent blockbusters. It’s so pleasantly surprising to see a studio give this much artistic freedom to a film with such a high budget.
It is also great that the filmmakers took more artistic license when adapting from the source material. Many fans have complained that the film’s ending feels anticlimactic due to the excision of a big battle scene. While I can understand this disappointment, it does not bother me. To me, the ending of “Order of the Phoenix” – with all of its crazy wand effects – feels vapid and emotionless, while this most recent film’s ending feels more psychological and impactful.
In conclusion, the “Potter” films will never be masterpieces like Peter Jackson’s “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy. The source material’s complexity, as well as several inconsistencies in direction and writing, prevents it from being so. Still, “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince” manages to capture the characters from the books and present them in an artful way. And that’s more than one can say for most Hollywood films.
B+ [More of a
B in terms of quality, but I really enjoyed it as a Potter fan, so I gave it a boost.]
Thanks for reading! Leave your opinion in the comments below.